On 25 September 2026 Shopify announced a change to how return fees are taxed, and it took effect four weeks later, on 23 October. The Help Center puts it in one sentence: "Starting October 23, 2026, tax is calculated on return shipping fees if the order was shipped to an address in the United States and you use one of the following tax services: Shopify Tax or Tax Platform."
For a store that offers free returns, nothing changes. For a store that charges a return shipping fee, collects tax through Shopify Tax, and has been handling the tax on that fee some other way, something does, and the date fell just before the busiest returns season of the year. This is what the change covers, what it leaves alone, and what to check now that it applies.
From 23 October 2026, Shopify charges tax on return shipping fees for orders shipped to US addresses on stores using Shopify Tax or Tax Platform, as its changelog announced on 25 September 2026. It does not apply to restocking fees, which Shopify does not tax, nor to stores using another tax service such as Manual Tax or Basic Tax, orders shipped outside the United States, or tax exempt orders. The practical risk is in the workarounds stores built before the change, such as adding tax into the return fee by hand, which would now count it twice. The sections below cover which fees it touches, the workarounds to remove, and a short list of checks to make now. A store that charges a flat return shipping fee to US customers should check one return through to the refund after the date, so the tax on the receipt is the amount it expects.
Shopify's changelog says return shipping fees will be taxed like any other shipping charge. When a return is created, Shopify shows the estimated tax on the fee; when the return is processed, it records the final tax, and that tax flows into your tax reports automatically.
Your existing shipping tax settings still decide the outcome. If you have set shipping to be untaxed in a state, return shipping fees in that state remain untaxed. And Shopify's return rules page adds the underlying rule: "Tax is calculated only if the fee is taxable in the tax jurisdiction that the order was shipped to." The change does not make a fee taxable where the law does not; it makes Shopify calculate the tax where it does.
In practice that means two customers returning the same product under the same policy can see different totals. One, in a state that taxes shipping, sees the return fee with a tax line on it; the other, in a state that does not, sees the fee alone. Both are correct, and a line on the returns page saying that tax may apply to the return fee where the law requires it saves the support team explaining it one customer at a time.
Shopify lists the cases where no tax is calculated on return fees: the order was shipped to an address outside the United States; you use another tax service, such as Manual Tax or Basic Tax; or the order is tax exempt. Separately, "Tax isn't calculated on restocking fees", whichever service you use.
So the stores this touches are US stores on Shopify Tax or Tax Platform that charge a return shipping fee on domestic orders. International orders follow their own rules, and for those the questions that matter are the ones about
duties at checkout and who pays them, not this one.
Shopify's return rules give three choices for return shipping: "Offer free return shipping," "Add a flat rate return shipping fee that's charged one time per return," or "Have your customers buy their own return shipping label." Separately, you can charge a restocking fee "that is a percentage of the return."
Read against the change, only the second choice produces a fee for Shopify to tax. Free returns carry no fee. A customer who buys their own label pays the carrier, not you. A restocking fee is a fee, but Shopify does not tax it. The flat rate return shipping fee is the one that has carried a tax line since 23 October in the states where shipping is taxable.
That fee is usually set by the same arithmetic as outbound shipping: what the carrier charges, what the customer will accept, and what it does to conversion. If you worked yours out alongside
a free shipping threshold, the tax does not change what you receive, but it does change what the customer sees deducted, and that is worth knowing before they ask.
A return fee that is now taxed changes the refund the customer receives, slightly. A customer who notices a number they did not expect writes to the store, so it is worth knowing what they will see before they ask.
The fee and its tax come out of the refund, by hand. Shopify does not deduct return fees from refunds automatically; whoever creates the refund deducts them. Where a store charges a flat return shipping fee, the refund is the price paid less the fee, and from 23 October 2026, on stores this change reaches and in places where shipping is taxed, the fee carries tax as well. Make sure whoever processes refunds knows, so the amounts are deducted the same way every time.
Show it before the return is started. The return policy and the returns flow should state the return shipping fee and that tax may apply to it. A customer who was told in advance rarely complains about a deduction they expected.
Keep it consistent across products. Stores using return window overrides by product or collection may also vary how returns are charged. Each combination the customer can meet should be described clearly.
Shopify return window overrides covers setting different rules by product, collection and market.
Prepare the support answer. A short, accurate reply explaining that the return shipping fee is now taxed, as shipping is, turns most of these messages into a minute's work.
Shopify's changelog told merchants who had been handling this manually to review their process before 23 October, to avoid duplicate tax calculations, and a store that has not reviewed it yet should do so now. Manual handling tends to take a few forms: a return fee set higher to cover the tax, tax on return fees added in a spreadsheet at filing time, or an app or accounting rule that records it separately. Since the change, each of those counts the tax a second time on every return it touches.
One thing does not change, and it catches people. "Return fees aren't automatically deducted from refunds. When you create a refund, you need to manually deduct any applicable return fees." A refund process written months ago as deduct the flat fee is worth rereading with whoever processes refunds, so they deduct what the return actually shows now that the fee can carry tax.
Confirm which tax service the store uses. If it is Manual Tax or Basic Tax, this change does not reach you.
Open your return rules and note which return shipping option is set. If it is free returns or customer-bought labels, you are done with the fee itself.
If you charge a flat rate return fee, check your state shipping tax settings, since they decide where the fee is taxed.
Find and remove any manual step that already adds tax to return fees, and tell whoever files your sales tax that return shipping has appeared in Shopify's tax reports since 23 October.
Brief whoever answers customer emails. A shopper who sees tax on a return fee for the first time will ask why, usually in January, when the gifts come back. If your
BFCM checklist includes the returns policy, add this line to it.
And while the return rules are open, it is worth looking at what returns actually cost you. The arithmetic in
what a return rate costs was written for Walmart, but the sums work the same way on a Shopify store.
The change is small per return and real in the books. Whoever prepares the store's sales tax filings should hear about it before the first filing that includes it, not after a figure looks wrong.
The date. From 23 October 2026, tax is calculated on return shipping fees for US orders on stores using Shopify Tax or Tax Platform. Filings covering periods across that date will include some returns taxed the old way and some the new way.
Where it appears. The tax collected on return fees is recorded with the returns, and the store's tax reports reflect it. Ask the accountant to check the first month's report after the change against a handful of actual returns.
Any manual handling that stopped. If the store used to adjust return fees by hand to account for tax, the date it stopped matters, because returns processed both ways in the same period need treating consistently in the filing.
States that do not tax shipping. Whether shipping charges are taxable depends on the state, and the return fee follows the same rules. The accountant will know which states the store files in and whether they tax shipping; the store should confirm its tax settings match.
A short note with these points, sent once, saves a longer conversation at filing time.
Most store return policies were written once and never revisited. A change to how return fees are taxed is a good moment to reread the policy as a customer would, and fix more than the one line.
State the fee plainly. If the store charges for return shipping, say how much, when it applies and that applicable taxes are added. If returns are free, say so clearly, since that is a reason to buy.
Say how refunds are calculated. The price refunded, what is deducted and why, and how long the refund takes once the return arrives. Customers forgive deductions they understood in advance far more readily than ones they discover.
Match the settings. The policy page, the return rules in the admin and any return windows set by product or collection should all say the same thing. A policy page that promises free returns while the store charges a fee is a complaint, and in some places a legal problem, waiting to happen.
Keep it findable. Link the policy from the product pages, the cart, the order confirmation and the returns flow, so a customer never has to search for it.
Date it. Note when the policy was last updated. It tells customers it is current and gives the store a record of what applied when.
For the Shopify stores we run, a change like this is a settings check and a process check, done once, as soon as the change applies: the tax service, the return rules, the state settings, the refund steps, and the note to the accountant. None of it is complicated, and all of it is easy to miss in the weeks before Black Friday, which is why it goes on the same list as the rest of
Shopify store management.