On 31 August 2026 the Federal Trade Commission and 22 states sued Amazon in the US District Court for the Western District of Washington over the auction that prices Sponsored Products ads. The complaint alleges that Amazon told advertisers they were in a second price auction while a hidden surcharge made them pay their own bid most of the time.
These are allegations. No court has ruled on them, and the FTC's announcement does not include Amazon's response. But the question underneath them, how close a click's cost sits to the bid placed for it, is one every advertiser can answer from their own reports today. This is what the case says, what it does not settle, and what to check in an account while it runs.
On 31 August 2026 the FTC and 22 states sued Amazon over how Sponsored Products clicks are priced. The complaint alleges that Amazon described a second price auction, where the winner pays one cent more than the next highest bid, while a hidden surcharge, which the complaint says Amazon called a soft reserve price, made advertisers pay their own bid close to 80% of the time.
Those are allegations. No court has ruled, Amazon's response is not in the announcement, and there is no refund process for advertisers, so anybody selling the recovery of an alleged surcharge today is selling something the case has not produced.
What an advertiser can do now does not depend on the outcome. Put the average cost per click beside the bid for each target that spent last month: where the two sit close together week after week, the account is paying its bid, whatever the auction is called. Then set each bid from what a click is worth, the order value times the conversion rate times the share of the sale you are willing to spend on advertising, and treat the bid as the price. Placement adjustments that raise a bid raise the price as well, on that reading.
Three things are worth watching as the case runs: Amazon's answer in court, any change in how Amazon describes its auction to advertisers, and whether any remedy the court or a settlement sets out reaches advertisers themselves. Until one of those changes, the auction to bid in is the one running today.
The FTC says Amazon described its ads as "'second price' auctions where the winner of the auction would only pay 'one cent more than the next highest bidder'", and that "Amazon has made these or similar representations on its website, in training videos and in other public-facing materials."
Against that, it alleges "a surcharge hidden in it", which it says Amazon called a "soft reserve price" and which internal documents describe with phrases including "invented auction participant", "proxy 2nd price that we calculate" and "shill bids". The effect it alleges is that "Amazon has charged its Sponsored Products advertisers their own winning bid close to 80% of the time."
The figures in the announcement are large. "The percentage of the time advertisers paid the amount of their bid increased from between 30% and 40% in 2021, to 70% in 2022, and to approximately 80% in 2024." The FTC puts the result at "tens of billions of dollars of revenue", from "over one million brands and sellers", including "500,000 small- and medium-sized businesses."
In a second price auction, the bid is a ceiling rather than a price. The winner pays just above the next highest bid, so an advertiser can bid the most a click is worth to them and expect to pay less most of the time. That is the logic most bidding advice is built on, including the advice to bid your true value and let the auction find the price, and it is how
Amazon PPC is usually explained.
If the winner pays their own bid most of the time, the bid is the price. Every bid set on the assumption of a discount has cost more than its owner planned, and every target set from those costs is out by the same amount.
What a click costs and what moves it sets out the other forces on the price; the case is about whether the auction itself was one of them.
Whatever the court decides about the auction, two settings in every Sponsored Products campaign already decide how far above its base bid a campaign can pay. Many advertisers have them switched on without having read them closely.
Dynamic bidding. Each campaign uses one of three bidding strategies. Fixed bids use the bid as set. Dynamic bids down only lowers the bid when a click looks less likely to convert. Dynamic bids up and down can also raise it, by up to 100 percent for the top of search placement and up to 50 percent elsewhere, when a click looks more likely to convert.
Placement adjustments. A campaign can add a percentage to its bids for the top of search, the rest of search and product pages, up to 900 percent. The adjustment applies on top of the base bid.
Together. A base bid of one dollar with a 100 percent top of search adjustment and the up and down strategy can bid up to four dollars for a top of search click: two dollars after the adjustment, doubled by the strategy. If, as the complaint alleges, winners often pay close to what they bid, those multipliers decide the price more than the base bid does.
What to do. Read each campaign's strategy and adjustments alongside its bids, and set them on purpose. A campaign meant to be cautious should not carry an up and down strategy and a large placement adjustment by default.
It does not establish that the allegations are true. Amazon has not had its say in court, and the announcement does not quote a response. The announcement does not set out the remedies being sought, and there is no refund process for advertisers. Anybody offering to recover an advertiser's share of the alleged surcharge today is selling something the case has not produced.
It also does not change how the auction works tomorrow. Whatever the outcome, an advertiser's bids are running in the auction as it is now, which is the one thing within their control.
Compare cost per click with the bid. In the Sponsored Products targeting and search term reports, put the average cost per click beside the bid for each keyword or target that has spent in the last month. Where cost per click sits at or just below the bid week after week, the account is paying its bid, whatever the auction is called.
Reading the search terms report covers where those numbers live.
Look at the targets where the gap is widest and narrowest. A keyword that costs well under its bid is a keyword where competition sets the price; one that costs almost exactly its bid is one where the bid does. Those are the bids that deserve attention first, because they are the ones where every cent of the bid is a cent spent.
Check the settings that raise bids. Placement adjustments and bidding strategies that increase a bid for top of search raise the price paid as well, if the price paid is the bid. They are worth reviewing on that basis, not only on the sales they bring.
A single month's comparison of cost per click with the bid is a snapshot. The same comparison kept over months shows how an account's clicks are actually priced, which is the evidence that matters whatever the case concludes.
Keep the ratio, target by target. For each keyword or target that spends, record the average cost per click divided by the bid, each month. A ratio that sits near one means clicks are being bought close to the bid; a ratio well below it means the auction is leaving room.
Account for the multipliers. Where a campaign uses dynamic bidding or placement adjustments, compare cost per click with the effective bid, not the base bid, or the ratio will look higher than it is.
Look for changes, not levels. A ratio that rises across many targets at once, with no change in bids, strategy or competition, is worth noting and dating. A ratio that rises for one target usually means more advertisers are bidding on it.
Keep the bid history. The campaign history in the advertising console records each change to bids and settings. Exported alongside the monthly ratios, it is the record that lets an advertiser say what it bid, when, and what it paid.
The point is not to second guess every click. It is to know, from the account's own data, how close to the bid its clicks are priced, and to bid accordingly.
Set each bid from what a click is worth, not from what the auction might charge. A click is worth the average order value, times the conversion rate, times the share of that order you are willing to spend on advertising. A product selling at $40 that converts one click in ten, with a 25% advertising cost of sale target, is worth $1.00 a click. Bid that, and treat it as the price.
Then judge the result on the measures that matter.
ACoS, TACoS and ROAS each answer a different question, and a bid that looks expensive against one can be right against another. The bids that pay their own way at their full value are the ones that survive whatever the case decides.
For a brand whose advertising is run by an agency, a freelancer or software, the case is a good prompt to ask how bids are actually set. The answers should be specific.
How is each bid decided? The best answer starts from what a click is worth to the product: order value, conversion rate and the share of the order the brand will spend on advertising. An answer that starts from the suggested bid alone is an answer about the auction, not about the brand.
Which bidding strategy does each campaign use, and why? Up and down, down only or fixed should be a choice made per campaign, with a reason, not a default left as created.
What placement adjustments are set? And what is the highest effective bid any campaign can reach once the adjustment and the strategy are applied. The person managing the bids should know that number.
Do any tools change bids automatically? Rules and software that raise bids on their own can push effective bids well past what anybody would set by hand. Ask what limits they run within.
Is cost per click read against the bid? Monthly, by target, with the history kept. If it is not, ask for it to start; it is the simplest protection an advertiser has, and it costs an hour a month.
Bids set from value, and cost per click read against them, are the discipline our
Amazon Advertising service is built on, and this case makes that check worth doing in every account. For an account that has not been looked at closely for a while,
the audit that finds wasted spend is the wider review to run alongside it.